Carte 3 · Leçon 2 sur 3 · ~8 min
Why depth counts twice
Les leçons sont en anglais pour l'instant.
Take a plastic ruler. Bend it lying flat: easy. Turn it on its edge and bend it again: you can hardly move it. Same ruler, same plastic, same amount of it. The only thing that changed is which way it stands.
This lesson is about why, because the wall bracket is that ruler standing on edge, and getting it the wrong way round is the most common mistake on the challenge.
Tap a symbol to find it in the drawing.
- Z
- the section modulus of a rectangle, in mm³
- t
- its thickness: the width across the bending, in mm
- b
- its depth: the dimension in the plane of the bending, in mm
- T
- the pull of the stretched half
- C
- the push of the squeezed half
In one sentence
A rectangle's bending strength grows with its thickness, and with the square of its depth.
Where it comes from
Follow the picture. The top half of the section is stretched, the bottom half squeezed, and the stress grows from zero at the middle to σ at each edge.
- How hard each half pushes. On average the stress over a half is
σ / 2, and a half has an area oft · b / 2. So each half pushes withT = C = σ / 2 · t · b / 2 = σ · t · b / 4. - How far apart the pushes are. A triangle's push acts a third of the way in from its wide end. So
TandCsit2b / 3apart. - The moment they carry. A push times its distance:
M = σ · t · b / 4 · 2b / 3 = σ · t · b² / 6.
So M = σ · Z, with Z = t · b² / 6. The depth b appears twice: once because a deeper plate has more steel pushing, once because the pushes sit further apart. That is why it is squared, and t is not.
Check it makes sense
- Units. mm × mm² = mm³.
- Twice the depth, four times the
Z. Twice the thickness, only twice. - The ruler. On edge against flat, the ratio is
(t · b²) / (b · t²) = b / t. A ruler six times wider than it is thick is six times stronger on edge.
The trap
The plate lying flat. b · t² / 6 is the formula with depth and thickness swapped: the bracket turned to lie flat, like the ruler you bent easily. On the practice plate it gives 320 mm³ instead of 1200 mm³, weaker by b / t. The brief's edge view exists only to stop this: b is the dimension in the plane of the load.
Worked, on the practice bracket
The practice plate, 30 mm deep, at the 8 mm thickness strength chose:
| Working | Result | |
|---|---|---|
| On edge, as it is bolted | Z = t · b² / 6 = 8 × 30² / 6 | 1200 mm³ |
| Lying flat, the trap | b · t² / 6 = 30 × 8² / 6 | 320 mm³ |
It needs 981 mm³ (lesson 1). On edge the plate has more than that; lying flat it would have far less.
Your turn, half done
A plate 10 mm thick and 40 mm deep stands on edge. Z = t · b² / 6 = 10 × 40² / 6. Finish it.
40² = 40 × 40; times 10, over 6: 2667 mm³.
Your turn
A lintel plate stands on edge: 50 mm deep, 12 mm thick. What is its section modulus?
Z = t · b² / 6 = 12 × 50² / 6 = 5000 mm³.
Check yourself
A steel strip 30 mm wide and 6 mm thick is bent first on edge, then flat. On edge, how much stronger is it?
5 times. On edge Z = t · b² / 6, flat Z = b · t² / 6; divide one by the other and b / t = 30 / 6 is left.
What you can do now: say why a plate on edge is so much stronger than a plate lying flat, and work out its section modulus. Next: turn the section modulus you need into a plate you can buy.
Étape 1 sur 11 · ~8 min restantes