Card 4 · Lesson 1 of 2 · ~8 min
Strong is not stiff
A diving board is strong: it carries a diver a thousand times and never breaks. It is also not stiff: it bends a long way, which is the whole point of it.
A bracket is the opposite. Strength (Card 3) says it will not bend for good. It says nothing about how far it bends while loaded: a bracket can be perfectly strong and still sag enough to tilt the hoist and swing the chain off line. This lesson measures the sag.
Tap a symbol to find it in the drawing.
- δ
- the tip deflection: how far the tip drops under the load, in mm
- W
- the load at the tip, in N
- L
- the lever arm, from the centre of the bolts to the load, in mm
- E
- Young's modulus: how stiff the steel itself is, in MPa
- I
- the second moment of area: how stiff the shape is, t · b³ / 12 for our plate, in mm⁴
In one sentence
The tip drops more for a heavier load and much more for a longer arm, and less for stiffer steel and a stiffer shape.
Where it comes from
Three things, each worth knowing on its own.
E, the steel's stiffness. How much stress it takes to stretch steel by a given share of its length. It is the slope of the straight line in Card 2's picture, and it is the same for every structural steel: S355 is stronger than S235, but not stiffer. The brief givesE= 210 000 MPa.I, the shape's stiffness. Close cousin ofZ:I = Z · b / 2, which ist · b³ / 12for a rectangle. One morebthanZ, because for stiffness a fibre far from the middle counts once for its push, once for its lever, and once more for how far it stretches.L³, the length three times over. The moment grows withL(Card 1). The plate bends along all ofL. And the small angle it turns through at the root is carried out a distanceLto the tip. ThreeLs. The 3 underneath comes from adding the bending up along a moment that falls fromW · Lat the root to nothing at the tip: take that one on trust here.
Check it makes sense
- Units. N · mm³ ÷ (MPa · mm⁴) = N · mm³ ÷ (N/mm² · mm⁴) = mm.
- Twice as long, eight times the sag.
Lis cubed. Long brackets are usually decided by stiffness, not strength. - Twice as deep, an eighth of the sag. Twice as thick, only half.
The trap
E in GPa. Books often print steel's E in gigapascals. Put that number into a formula where everything else is in N and mm and E is a thousand times too small, so the sag is a thousand times too big. In N and mm, E is in MPa: 210 000.
And I with b and t swapped, the plate lying flat again: it is wrong by (b / t)², far worse than the factor it cost in Z.
Worked, on the practice bracket
The practice bracket at the 8 mm plate strength chose, step 7:
| Working | Result | |
|---|---|---|
| The shape | I = t · b³ / 12 = 8 × 30³ / 12 | 18 000 mm⁴ |
| The sag | δ = W · L³ / (3 · E · I) = 245.25 × 440³ / (3 × 210 000 × 18 000) | 1.8423 mm |
Under two millimetres. Is that a lot? The next lesson says.
Your turn, half done
A load of 300 N at the tip of a plate 400 mm long, 40 mm deep and 8 mm thick. Set up for you: I = 8 × 40³ / 12, and δ = 300 × 400³ / (3 × 210 000 × I). Finish it: how far does the tip drop?
I = 8 × 40³ / 12 mm⁴, and then δ = 0.71429 mm.
Your turn
A steel bracket, 45 mm deep and 10 mm thick, carries 520 N at its tip, 550 mm from the centre of its bolts. How far does the tip sag?
I = t · b³ / 12 = 10 × 45³ / 12, then δ = W · L³ / (3 · E · I) = 1.8084 mm.
Check yourself
The same plate and the same load, but the bracket is made twice as long. How much further does the tip sag?
Eight times. L is cubed: 2 × 2 × 2. Its moment doubles, it bends over twice the length, and it carries its root angle twice as far.
What you can do now: say why a strong bracket can still be too bendy, and work out how far its tip sags. That is step 7 of the wall bracket challenge.
Part 1 of 11 · ~8 min left